Sunday, April 19, 2015

The IMF on Investment since 2008

Vox today has a useful piece by five IMF economists on the behavior of business investment during and since the Great Recession. [1] From my point of view, there are three important points here.


1. The most important difference between this cycle and previous ones is the larger fall and slower recovery of private investment. This has always been my view, and I think it's an especially important point for heterodox folks to take on board because there has been such (excessive, in my opinion) emphasis on the inequality-consumption link in explaining persistent demand weakness.

This relationship between output and investment is consistent with previous recessions: 
business investment has deviated little from what could be expected given the weakness in economic activity. In other words, firms have reacted to weak sales – both current and prospective – by reducing capital spending. Indeed, in surveys, businesses typically report lack of customer demand as the dominant challenge they face.
In other words, the old Keynesian "accelerator" story explains the bulk of the shortfall in investment since 2008.


2. Historically, deviations in output and investment has been persistent; there is no tendency for recessions to be followed by a return to the previous trend. 

The blue line shows the behavior of output and investment in recessions historically, relative to the pre-recession trend. Note that is no tendency for the gap to close, as much as six years after the previous peak.

The authors don't emphasize this point, but it is important. If we look at recessions across a range of industrialized countries, on average the output losses are permanent. There is no tendency for output to return to the pre-trend. If this is true, there's no basis for the conventional distinction between a demand-determined "short run" and a supply-determined "long run." There is just one dynamic process. Steve Fazzari has reached this same conclusion, as I've written about here. Roger Farmer has just posted an econometric demonstration that in the postwar US, output changes are persistent -- there is no tendency to return to a trend.


 3. There's no reason to think that the investment deficit is explained by financial constraints. I should say frankly that the paper didn't move my priors much at all on this point, but it's still interesting that that's what it says. By their estimates, firms in more "financially-dependent" sectors (this is a standard technique, but whatever) initially reduced investment more than firms in less financially-dependent sectors, but as of 2013 investment in both groups of firms were the same 40 percent below the pre-crisis trend. If you believe these results -- and again, I don't put much weight on them, except as an indicator of the IMF flavor of received opinion -- then while tighter credit may have helped trigger the crisis, it cannot explain the persistent weakness of demand. Or from a policy perspective -- and the authors do say this -- measures to improve access to credit are unlikely to achieve much, at least relative to measures to boost demand.


Investment by sector

So these are features it might be nice to incorporate into a macro model -- investment determined mainly by (changes in) current output; a single system of demand-based dynamics, as opposed to a short-run demand story and a long-run supply-based steady state growth path; a possibility of multiple equilibria, such that (let's say) a temporary interruption of credit flows can produce a persistent reduction in output.  On one level I don't especially trust these results. But on another level, I think they provide a good set of stylized facts that macro models should aspire to parsimoniously explain. 

[1] The European Vox, not the Klein-Yglesias one.


UPDATE: Krugman today points to the same work and also interprets it as support for an accelerator story.

94 comments:

  1. " The most important difference between this cycle and previous ones is the larger fall and slower recovery of private investment. This has always been my view, and I think it's an especially important point for heterodox folks to take on board because there has been such (excessive, in my opinion) emphasis on the inequality-consumption link in explaining persistent demand weakness."

    I don't think the heterodox folks will be convinced. I know I'm not.

    The IMF says that the lackluster investment is a result of weak demand. Weak demand was the problem in the 2000s , alleviated for a period only by means of a huge debt bubble , it's a problem currently , and it's a problem going forward. This fits perfectly with an inequality/consumption thesis.

    Marko

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. WELCOME TO BETTERMENT FUNDINGS {bettermentfunding@gmail.com}

      our aims is to provide Excellent Professional Service.

      Our loans are well insured for maximum security is our priority, Our leading goal is to help you get the services you deserve, Our program is the quickest way to get what you need in a snap. Reduce your payments to ease the strain on your monthly expenses. Gain flexibility with which you can use for any purpose – from vacations, to education, to unique purchases

      Are you a business man or woman? Are you in any financial mess or do you need funds to start up your own business? Do you need a loan to start a nice Small Scale and medium business? Do you have a low credit score and you are finding it hard to obtain capital loan from local banks and other financial institutes?.

      We offer a wide range of financial services which includes: Personal Loans, Debt consolidation loans, Business Loans, Education Loans, Mortgage Secured Loan, Unsecured loan, Mortgage Loans, Payday off Loans, Student Loans, Commercial Loans, Car Loans, Investments Loans, Development Loans, Acquisition Loans, Construction Loans, with low interest rate at 2% per annul for individuals, companies and corporate bodies. Get the best for your family and own your dream home as well with our General Loan scheme.

      If you are interested to get a loan then kindly write us with the loan requirement.Please, contact us for more information: bettermentfunding@gmail.com

      We look forward to hear from you ASAP

      Interested applicants should Contact us via email: bettermentfunding@gmail.com

      Delete
    2. HOW I BECAME A VICTOR AFTER SO MANY FAILED ATTEMPT OF GETTING A LOAN.

      I feel so blessed and fulfilled. I've been reluctant in applying for a loan i heard about online because everything seems too good to be true, but i was convinced & shocked when my friend at my place of work got a loan from Progresive Loan INC. & we both confirmed it and i also went ahead to apply, today am a proud owner of my company and making money for my family and a happy mom. Well i'm Annie Joe by name from Pauls Valley, Oklahoma. As a single mom with three kids it was hard to get a job that could take care of me and my kids and I had so much bills to pay and to make it worst I had bad credit so i couldn't obtain a loan from any bank. I had an ideal to start a business as an hair stylist but had no capital to start, Tried all type of banks but didn't work out until I was referred by my co-worker to a godsent lender advertising to give a loan at 2% interest rate. I sent them a mail using their official email address (progresiveloan@yahoo.com) and I got a reply immediately and my loan was approved, and I was directed to the Bank site where I withdrawed my loan directly to my account. To cut the story short am proud of my hair stylist company and promise to testify to the world how my life was transformed.. If you are in need of any kind of loan, i advise you contact Progresive Loan INC and be financially lifted Email: progresiveloan@yahoo.com OR Call/Text +1(603) 786-7565



      Delete
  2. I think it is certainly false that inequality led in any straightforward way to to higher debt; I think it is false that there has been a tendency for aggregate desired consumption to be lower at full employment than in the past; I think it's possible that higher inequality has been one factor among others contributing to weaker demand; and I think it's unlikely that it is the most important factor, and possible that it is not a factor at all.

    I realize that a lot of people believe that the inequality --> lower consumption demand story is central to recent macroeconomic history, and that to convince them I need to make a stronger empirical case than I have so far. We'll keep at it.

    ReplyDelete
  3. As one who (as you well know) is forever beating his spoon on the highchair about the inequality/consumption thesis, I'll just say:

    It may not be the most important driver of the (very convincing) weak-demand story you tell above, but it comports seamlessly with that story.

    Just as macro models should incorporate and address the "stylized facts" and explanations you lay out above, they should also (far more frequently?) incorporate the rather straightforwardly arithmetic Marginal Propensity to Spend Out of Wealth/Income effect.

    (I think that representative-agent models, by their very nature, are incapable of doing so -- you can't model concentration/distribution of wealth/income across a single agent. But would be interested to hear otherwise.)

    ReplyDelete
  4. Just as macro models should incorporate and address the "stylized facts" and explanations you lay out above, they should also (far more frequently?) incorporate the rather straightforwardly arithmetic Marginal Propensity to Spend Out of Wealth/Income effect.

    I agree that all else equal, a higher share of income at the top will imply lower desired consumption at a given level of aggregate income. In the real world, though, all else is never equal, and changes in income distribution may or may not be an important factor in any given shift in the consumption function. In the case of recent US history, I think the effect is largely swamped by (1) increased consumption of status-goods by the rich and (2) and increased share of social consumption. (The second factor is hardly discussed since the fact that an increasing share of consumption is collective doesn't fit any prevailing political narrative.) We also shouldn't ignore demographics.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I think that representative-agent models, by their very nature, are incapable of doing so -- you can't model concentration/distribution of wealth/income across a single agent.

    Agree. But this is like finding another reason why the moon isn't made of green cheese.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Stylized facts and vacuous interpretations
    Comment on ‘The IMF on Investment since 2008’

    Obviously your post lacks an underlying coherent theory. To make a long argument (2015) short, the correct employment equation for the investment economy is given here:
    https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:AXEC46.png

    The equation says that employment L increases with
    • investment expenditures I,
    • an increasing expenditure ratio rhoE (=C/Y),
    • an increasing factor cost ratio rhoF (=W/PR),
    under the condition of product market clearing if price P and productivity R in the consumption and investment good industry as well as distributed profit Yd remain unaltered in the period under consideration; it decreases in the opposite case. The testable equation explains unemployment.

    The income distribution affects the expenditure ratio rhoE. The dependency of the average expenditure ratio from wage income and distributed profit and their different expenditure ratios is given with eq. (30) in (2014).

    The employment equation above accounts coherently for both the effects of investment expenditures and distributional changes (and a bit more).

    It is important to note that distribution theory crucially depends on profit theory. It is very probable that your profit theory is false (again see 2014) and therefore your interpretation of the IMF data is pointless.

    Egmont Kakarot-Handtke

    References
    Kakarot-Handtke, E. (2014). The Profit Theory is False Since Adam Smith. What
    About the True Distribution Theory? SSRN Working Paper Series, 2511741:
    1–23. URL http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=2511741.
    Kakarot-Handtke, E. (2015). Essentials of Constructive Heterodoxy: Employment.
    SSRN Working Paper Series, 2576867:

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Gerard Dumenil once told me something very wise:

      "The error of idealism is to confuse the production of theoory with the exposition of theory; the latter builds up logicallly from the simplest concepts, while the former cannot. Exposition can follow a deductive method, but the original development of theory cannot."

      Right now, I am trying to develop a theory. That is different from the exposition of an already developed theory. When you are trying to produce theory, you can't start from a formalization with axioms and so on. You have to start from a concrete reality.

      Delete
  7. "income distribution may or may not be an important factor in any given shift in the consumption function"

    I think more in terms of the "spending" function than the consumption function. C vs I is somewhat secondary. Also spending relative to wealth vs income; different measures might suggest more or less "important." Social spending: very good point.

    I have to go back to that Fazzari paper now, and your post on it...

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. You are right that the C vs I distinction is arbitrary and probably not that important for the questions we are interested in. I still hope to convince you that the expenditure-income relation matters in a way that the expenditure-welath relation does not -- not because income necessarily plays a bigger role in expenditure decisions than wealth does, but because income-expenditure makes a closed loop with the possibility of positive feedback in a way that expenditure-wealth does not. From a macro standpoint, the point isn't that income affects expenditure more than wealth does; it is that income affects expenditure AND expenditure determines income, whereas the wealth-expenditure link is more one way.

      Delete
  8. I absolutely loved reading this post. It is informative, completely comprehensive and straight to the point.. intraday tips

    ReplyDelete
  9. Cable Suppliers And Cable Manufacturers

    Mandeep Cables Pvt Ltd one of the leading manufacturer of Cable, Wire, Networking cables, USB Cable a name for excellence and quality engaged in the manufacturing of diverse electric networking cables and Power cords and presently needs of the domestic market in a big way. Financially sound and capable of meeting and volume/quantity of material once the deal in through.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Do you need an urgent blank ATM CARD to solve your financial needs, My name is Linda Oscar, and i just want to tell the world my experience with everyone. i discovered a hacking guy called Christopher. he is really good at what he is doing, i inquired about the BLANK ATM CARD. if it works or even Exist, than i gave it a try and asked for the card and agreed to their terms and conditions. three days later i received my card and tried it with the closest ATM machine close to me, to my greatest surprise it worked like magic. i was able to withdraw up to 6000 euro. This was unbelievable and the happiest day of my life. there is no ATM MACHINES this BLANK ATM CARD CANNOT penetrate into it because it have been programmed with various tools and software. it impossible for the CCTV to detect you i don't know why i am posting this here, i just felt this might help those of us in need of financial stability. Christopher have really change my life. if you want to contact them, HERE is the email address: (blankatmcard661@gmail.com) His website(http://blankatmcard661.wix.com/blankcard) WhatsApp number +2348051122286

    ReplyDelete
  11. We offer personal loans up to $ 100,000, are you looking for a business loan and have been denied by a bank, we can help with loans of $ 5,000 to a maximum of $ 100,000 with just 3% interest rate you can have access to instant loans.we offer services to customers all over the world, we provide loans that can help you start your dream business,Rebuild and get your business back on track and can also bring you on a path to a better financial future. you can apply in just a few minutes with few steps and get your money the same day (24 hrs).
    Do not delay! E-mail via {smallscaleloans@gmail.com}
    Thank you for contacting us,
    Best regards
    Mr.George
    smallscaleloans@gmail.com

    ReplyDelete
  12. แฮนดิแคป Mandeep Cables Pvt Ltd one of the leading manufacturer

    ReplyDelete
  13. I’m no longer sure the place you are getting your info, but good topic. I needs to spend some time studying much more or figuring out more. Thank you for fantastic information I was looking for this info for my mission. Aderall Alternative

    ReplyDelete
  14. Hello! I could have sworn I’ve been to this blog before but after checking through some of the post I realized it’s new to me. Anyways, I’m definitely delighted I found it and I’ll be bookmarking and checking back often! testosterone cypionate online

    ReplyDelete
  15. Spot on with this write-up, I actually believe this amazing site needs much more consideration. I’ll oftimes be once again to learn additional, many thanks for that information. human growth hormone for sale

    ReplyDelete
  16. แทงบอลออนไลน์ The best online football betting website and has a form of football betting that can meet the needs of the gambler

    ReplyDelete

  17. fun88
    As a Newbie, I am continuously exploring online for articles that can benefit me. Thank you

    ReplyDelete
  18. เว็บพนัน88March 25, 2022 at 5:26 AM

    You can make money through our website easily. Trial subscriptions and play here. เว็บพนัน88

    ReplyDelete
  19. เว็บพนันออนไลน์April 29, 2022 at 6:06 AM

    เว็บพนันออนไลน์ New forms of gambling websites Besides the original casino games, we also have a wide variety of games for you to try out. Easy to play for real money

    ReplyDelete
  20. wm casino The best with the most modern and best system, stable, 100% secure

    ReplyDelete
  21. เว็บพนันMay 7, 2022 at 4:03 AM

    เว็บพนัน Online gambling sites Slot games and many more on your mobile phone. Convenient, fast, play anytime

    ReplyDelete
  22. Soccer bet is the most common bet and most worldwide because it pretty easy to bet and get a lot of money from it. เว็บ88

    ReplyDelete
  23. เว็บพนันMay 9, 2022 at 2:53 AM

    Everyone should try gambling at this site. I am very impressed with the service of the staff. เว็บพนัน

    ReplyDelete
  24. วิธีแทงหวย naza Can raise casino games into the online system, play anywhere, anytime.

    ReplyDelete
  25. เว็บพนันออนไลน์May 11, 2022 at 5:08 AM

    Lots of betting tricks for you to try. Don't worry you can make a lot of money from here. เว็บพนันออนไลน์

    ReplyDelete
  26. Online gambling sites That meet the needs of gamblers Excellently เว็บ 123

    ReplyDelete
  27. The most popular Online betting sites 24 hours a day, no holidays. แทงบอล

    ReplyDelete
  28. The most popular Online betting sites 24 hours a day, no holidays. แทงบอล 123dd

    ReplyDelete
  29. Slot games can be played anywhere. all the time on mobile แทงบอล 123dd

    ReplyDelete
  30. Live casino games Collected for the gambler The graphics are very playful ทางเข้า 123

    ReplyDelete
  31. ราคาแฮนดิแคป casino website that have all the betting in it to answer all the needed for the gambler

    ReplyDelete
  32. he most interesting thing in the world is online right now ราคาบอล

    ReplyDelete
  33. 123win ap Online gambling games are easy, convenient and fun.

    ReplyDelete
  34. The best casino in Thailand make good money 123คาสิโน

    ReplyDelete
  35. Welcome to The best online gambling sites now that everyone should try, here you will learn everything about online betting and earn money easily via any smartphone.เว็บ55 naza

    ReplyDelete
  36. Thank you to share this great post and your article is too good and informative for me. Keep writing and sharing educational article like this which can help us to grow our knowledge. I think it’s a really creative way to start a post, whether it’s an online article or blog post.

    ReplyDelete
  37. www.Elon777.com No.1 Online Casin0 (B@ccarat, R0ulette, PokeI2, S1ot , B!ackjacl<, etc.)
    Join with us LINE : @Elon
    #สล็อตแตกง่าย #หวยออนไลน์ #บาคาร่าฟรีเครดิต

    ReplyDelete
  38. สล็อตเว็บตรง เกมส์สล็อตออนไลน์ที่มาแรงที่สุดในตอนนี้และเป็นเกมส์สล็อตออนไลน์ที่มีผู้เล่นใช้บริการมากสุดในรอบปีเพราะเป็นเกมส์สล็อตออนไลน์. PG slot ที่มีตัวเกมส์น่าเล่น และมีตัวเกมส์ที่หลากหลายและยังเป็นตัวเกมส์ที่คนนิยมลงทุนมากที่สุดและเป็นตัวเกมส์สล็อตออนไลน์ที่มีเงินรางวัลแจกผู้เล่นมากกว่า 1 แสนยูสเซอร์

    ReplyDelete
  39. เว็บ123bet Mobile Casino Games Minimum bet 10 baht

    ReplyDelete
  40. บทความ pg slot แหล่งรวมบทความสล็อต เว็บไซต์พนันสล็อตออนไลน์ ที่ได้รับความนิยมที่มาพร้อมทั้ง PG Slot เกมสล็อตออนไลน์ ประสิทธิภาพ น่าเล่นที่ใครๆก็ต่างมีความสนใจอย่างยิ่ง 

    ReplyDelete
  41. เว็บสล็อต pg เว็บตรง123 The highlight of SA Casino is that it has an easy to use platform.

    ReplyDelete
  42. เว็บสล็อต 123 Number 1 online gambling website We have a system to refer friends that can make money easily. for all customers to use, convenient and easy

    ReplyDelete
  43. pg ช่วยหาเงินเติมเกม valorant เดี๋ยวนี้เล่นเกมอะไรก็ต้องใช้เงินเติมเพิ่มไอเทมเจ๋งๆไปอวดเพื่อนเว็บ pg ช่วยคุณได้เล่นเกมของเราได้เงินจริงไปต่อยอด เติมเกมอื่นๆได้อีกเพียบ

    ReplyDelete
  44. เว็บพนัน No need to go as far as the casino, you can gamble here. Just have a smartphone

    ReplyDelete
  45. เว็บพนัน88 Meet all needs of gamblers around the world Quality website The highest returns are number one.

    ReplyDelete
  46. gt66 สล็อต มีเกมสล็อตจากค่ายชั้นหนึ่งทั่วทั้งโลก มาให้บริการอย่างพร้อม ที่ผ่านการตรวจสอบมาแล้ว มีความถูกต้องต่อผู้เล่น pgslot เข้ามาเล่นแล้วสามารถทำเงินได้จริงตอบปัญหาได้

    ReplyDelete
  47. เว็บพนัน The most trusted online gambling website at the moment

    ReplyDelete
  48. เว็บพนันออนไลน์ Just guess the number of dice points and get paid easily via Sic Bo betting on our website.

    ReplyDelete
  49. Really great article. I'm glad to read the article.

    ReplyDelete
  50. It is very informative for us, thanks for posting.

    ReplyDelete
  51. Thank you so much for sharing this blog with us.

    ReplyDelete

  52. It provides a collection of useful information.

    ReplyDelete
  53. Fabulous! This is just amazing! Not just high quality, however additionally valuable info. And that is rare to come by nowadays!

    ReplyDelete

  54. I wan’t going to comment as this posts a bit old now, but just wanted to say thanks.

    ReplyDelete

  55. I really liked it. I wanted to leave a note. I was reading your website. I also tried to share the site.

    ReplyDelete
  56. This is the best way to share the great article with everyone one, so that everyone can able to utilize this information

    ReplyDelete
  57. 2024 Best Bank Nifty Telegram Channel in India
    https://banknifty.today/bank-nifty-telegram-channel/
    In the ever-evolving landscape of the stock market, traders constantly seek reliable, swift, and insightful sources of information. Among these, Best Bank Nifty Telegram channels have emerged as a pivotal resource, especially for those trading in the Indian stock market. Banknifty.today brings you an ultimate guide to the best Bank Nifty Telegram channels, catering to both novice and seasoned traders.

    ReplyDelete

  58. Really appreciate you sharing this blog Much thanks again. Want more.

    ReplyDelete
  59. Thank for making and spending your precious time for this useful information.

    ReplyDelete
  60. Thanks for ones marvelous posting! I certainly enjoyed reading it.

    ReplyDelete
  61. You may be a great author. Thank you!!

    ReplyDelete
  62. Thanks and Best of luck to your next Blog in future.

    ReplyDelete
  63. Wow, amazing blog format! The total look of your site is wonderful. Thanks.

    ReplyDelete
  64. Thanks for publishing such a unique and great article.

    ReplyDelete
  65. Very good write-up. I certainly love this site. Keep writing!

    ReplyDelete
  66. Such clever blog work and exposure! Keep up the very good works.

    ReplyDelete
  67. Thanks so much for this post, pretty worthwhile material.

    ReplyDelete
  68. I hope you will keep writing articles as good as this, so I gained extensive insight.

    ReplyDelete
  69. I definitely enjoying every little bit of it and I have you bookmarked to check out new stuff you post.

    ReplyDelete
  70. Thank you so much as you have been willing to share information with us.

    ReplyDelete

  71. Very nice article, I enjoyed reading your post, very nice share

    ReplyDelete