Thursday, January 8, 2015

Unemployment and Productivity Growth

I write here frequently about "the money view" -- the idea that we need to see economic relationships as a system of money flows and money commitments, that is not reducible to the "real" production and exchange of goods and services. Seeing the money-game as a self-contained system is the first step; the next step is to ask how this system interacts with the concrete activities of production.

One way to look at this interface is through the concept of potential output, and its relationship to current expenditure, or demand. In the textbook view, there is no connection between the long-run evolution of potential output with demand. This is a natural view if you think that economic quantities have an independent material existence. First we have scarce resources, then the choice about which end to devote them to. Knut Wicksell suggests somewhere an evocative metaphor for this view of economic growth: It's as if we had a cellar full off wine in barrels, which will improve with age. The problem of economic growth is then equivalent to choosing the optimal tradeoff between having better wine, and drinking it sooner than later. But whatever choice we make, all the wine is already there. Ramsey and Solow growth models, with their "golden rule" growth rate, are descriptions of this kind of problem. Aggregate demand doesn't come into it.

From our point of view, on the other hand, production is a creative, social activity. Economic growth is not a matter of allowing an exiting material process to continue operating through time, but of learning how to work together in new ways. The fundamental problem is coordination, not allocation.  From this point of view, the technical conditions of production are endogenous to the organization of production, and the money payments that structure it. So it's natural to think that aggregate expenditure could be an important factor determining the pace at which productive activity can be reorganized.

Now, whether demand actually does matter in the longer run is hotly debated point in heterodox economics. You can find very smart Post Keynesians like Steve Fazzari arguing that it does, and equally smart Marxists like Dumenil and Levy arguing that it does not. (Amitava Dutt has a good summary; Mark Setterfield has a good recent discussion of the formal issues of incorporating demand into Kaldorian growth models.) But within our framework, at least it is possible to ask the question.

Which brings me to this recent article in the Real World Economic Review. I don't recommend the piece -- it is not written in a way to inspire confidence. But it does make an interesting claim, that over the long run there is an inverse relationship between unemployment and labor productivity growth in the US, with average labor productivity growth equal to 8 minus the unemployment rate. This is consistent with the idea that demand conditions influence productivity growth, most obviously because pressures to economize on labor will be greater when labor is scarce.

A strong empirical regularity like this would be interesting, if it was real. But is it?

Here is one obvious test (a bit more sensible to me than the approach in the RWER article). The figure below shows the average US unemployment rate and real growth rate of hourly labor productivity for rolling ten-year windows.


It's not exactly "the rule of 8" -- the slope of the regression line is just a big greater than -0.5, rather than -1. But it is still a striking relationship. Ten-year periods with high growth of productivity invariably also have low unemployment rates; periods of high average unemployment are invariably also periods of slow productivity growth.

Of course these are overlapping periods, so this tells us much less than it would if they were independent observations. But the association of above-average productivity growth with below-average unemployment is indeed a historical fact, at least for the postwar US. (As it turns out, this relationship is not present in most other advanced countries -- see below.) So what could it mean?

1. It might mean nothing. We really only have four periods here -- two high-productivity-growth, low-unemployment periods, one in the 1950s-1960s and one in the 1990s; and two low-productivity-growth, high-unemployment periods, one in the 1970s-1980s and one in the past decade or so. It's quite possible these two phenomena have separate causes that just happened to shake out this way. It's also possible that a common factor is responsible for both -- a new technology-induced investment boom is the obvious candidate.

2. It might be that high productivity growth leads to lower unemployment. The story here I guess would be the Fed responding to a positive supply shock. I don't find this very plausible.

3. It might be that low unemployment, or strong demand in general, fosters faster productivity growth. This is the most interesting for our purposes. I can think of several versions of this story. First is the increasing-returns story that originally motivated Verdoorn's law. High demand allows firms to produce further out on declining cost curves. Second, low unemployment could encourage firms to adopt more labor-saving production techniques. Third, low unemployment might associated with more rapid movement of labor from lower-productivity to higher-productivity activities. (In other words, the relationship might be due to lower visible unemployment being associated with lower disguised unemployment.) Or fourth, low unemployment might be associated with a relaxing of the constraints that normally limit productivity-boosting investment -- demand itself, and also financing. In any of these stories, the figure above shows a causal relationship running from the x-axis to the y-axis.

One scatterplot of course hardly proves anything. I'm really just posing the question. Still, this one figure is enough to establish one thing: A positive relationship between unemployment and labor productivity has not been the dominant influence on either variable in the postwar US. In particular, this is strong evidence against the idea the idea of technological unemployment, beloved by everyone from Jeremy Rifkin to Lawrence Summers. (At least as far as this period is concerned -- the future could be different.) To tell a story in which paid labor is progressively displaced by machines, you must have a positive relationship between labor productivity and unemployment. But historically, high unemployment has been associated with slower growth in labor productivity, not faster. So we can say with confidence that whatever has driven changes in unemployment over the past 75 years, it has not been changes in the pace at which human labor is replaced by technology.

The negative relationship between unemployment and productivity growth, whatever it means, turns out to be almost unique to the US. Of the dozen or so other countries I looked at, the only one with a similar pattern is Japan, and even there the relationship is weaker. I honestly don't know what to make of this. But if you're interested, the other scatterplots are below the fold.
























Note: Labor productivity is based on real GDP per hour, from the BLS International Labor Comparisons project; unemployment is the harmonized unemployment rate for all persons from the OECD Main Economic Indicators database. I used these because they are (supposed to be) defined consistently across countries and were available on FRED. Because the international data covers shorter periods than the US data does, I used 8-year windows instead of 10-year windows.

74 comments:

  1. On possibility of reverse causation, aren't there explanations that have nothing to do with fed? Like an investment boom resulting in bother higher labour prod and lower unemp?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. 50Invest with 0$ and get a returns of 5,000$ within seven business working days.
      Why wasting your precious time online looking for a loan? When there is an opportunity for you to invest with 500$ and get a returns of 5,000$ within seven business working days. Contact us now for more information if interested on how you can earn big with just little amount. This is all about investing into  Crude Oil and Gas Business.

      Email: totalinvestmentcompany@gmail.com

      Delete
    2. This comment has been removed by the author.

      Delete
  2. The international comparisons do suggest the US relationship is accidental, particularly because they include countries like the UK which have also experienced the plutocratic revolution of the last thirty years, albeit in a somewhat milder form.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Abstract from your link to Setterfield :

    "Recent Kaldorian growth models emphasize the need to reconcile the demand-led actual
    rate of growth and the potential rate of growth. This issue is revisited in light of criticism
    suggesting it is a ‘red herring’. An explicit model of the supply side is used to show that, in a mature economy, it is unlikely that steady-state, demand-led growth will always be automatically accommodated by the supply side. The conclusion reached is that attention must, therefore, be paid to the possible emergence of supply constraints on growth, and the implications thereof for steady-state, demand-led growth models."

    This strikes me as unusually reasonable , and refreshing. Too many economists focus on only one side of the supply-demand co-dependency ( predominantly the supply side in recent decades ). I wish more would work on ways to diagnose whether the economy is bound by supply or demand constraints and on reasonably timely methods to detect when "crossover" to the other regime occurs.

    I also wish they'd stop talking as if they can say anything at all about "potential gdp" until they've first mastered the supply vs. demand question. Simply saturating the economy with credit ( and ever-growing leverage ) is not a valid way to relieve a demand shortfall , ( thus allowing a supply-side focus ) since it's not sustainable long-term.

    Thanks for the link. Nice set of graphs you made there , too.

    Marko

    ReplyDelete
  4. Thanks for sharing the info, keep up the good work going.... I really enjoyed exploring your site. good resource...
    time

    ReplyDelete
  5. I have been deceived and disappointed severally by alot of scammers all claiming to have the blank card and i lost a lot of money trying to get this but my story changed when i met DAVID BENJAMIN at first i was scared of falling for a fool again and did not want to give in but his words where convincing and to my greatest surprise they where true to them and in less than 3 days my card was delivered to my door step and it worked effectively using the manual guide was given.If you are in need of a true and reliable company then use davidbenjaminltd@outlook.com and worry no more

    ReplyDelete
  6. Keep it up for more update about this information. Visit Ogen Infosystem for the creative and responsive website designing.
    Website Designing Company

    ReplyDelete
  7. Nice information, visit Mutualfundwala for the best Mutual Fund Companies and Mutual Fund Agent in Delhi, India.
    Mutual Fund Companies

    ReplyDelete

  8. We have other cat breeds ready for adoption, Welcome to British Shorthair kittens cattery, home of Registered British shorthair kittens for sale. As Registered and well recognized British shorthair kittens breeder, we have been raising British Shorthair kittens since 2015.As British shorthair kittens breeder,we have extensive experience in breeding and grooming British Shorthair Kittens . We provide an opportunity to become an owner of our highly valued British shorthair kittes for sale which have been well trained and have all qualities of a good British Shorthair such as calmed personalities of British shorthair kittens and good tempers ,hypoallergenic kittens for sale.We equally provide shipping services to ensure your British Shorthair kitten arrives your location with no hassles. So feel at home adopt a British shorthair kitten online or adopt a British shorthair kitten near me with ease.
    Welcome to our farm where we breed Registered pomeranian puppies for sale.As a registered pomeranian puppies breeder, we have made it possible for pomeranian puppy lovers to
    buy pomeranian puppies online,buy zwergpitz pomeranian from our family run farm. Pomeranian dogs are small dogs with a weight of 1.36 to 3.17 kg and a withers height of 15 to 18 cm. They are compact but robust dogs with a lush, textured coat and a tall and flat tail. The top coat forms a fur ruff on the neck, for which poms are known, and on the hindquarters they have a margin of feathered hair.You can click HERE to view our available pomeranian puppies

    Hello, and welcome to our website for the best hand raised
    hand raised macaw parrots for sale. We pride ourselves in the best taming practices of macaws among aviaries. All of ourmacaws for sale are bred in a disease-free Biosecure breeding sanctuary. They are well socialized, having been raised in our home as members of our own family in order for them to become ready to be a member of yours, we have green wing macaw,severe macaw for sale,scarlet macaw for sale,blue and yellow macaw for sale among others. They are quite comfortable around all ages, including the elderly and young children. When you purchase a bird from Us, we are committed to offering lifetime support and guidance to you and your family.You can read more and view our available birds.You can
    READ MORE and view our avilable bird

    ReplyDelete

  9. We have other cat breeds ready for adoption, Welcome to British Shorthair kittens cattery, home of Registered British shorthair kittens for sale. As Registered and well recognized British shorthair kittens breeder, we have been raising British Shorthair kittens since 2015.As British shorthair kittens breeder,we have extensive experience in breeding and grooming British Shorthair Kittens . We provide an opportunity to become an owner of our highly valued British shorthair kittes for sale which have been well trained and have all qualities of a good British Shorthair such as calmed personalities of British shorthair kittens and good tempers ,hypoallergenic kittens for sale.We equally provide shipping services to ensure your British Shorthair kitten arrives your location with no hassles. So feel at home adopt a British shorthair kitten online or adopt a British shorthair kitten near me with ease.
    Welcome to our farm where we breed Registered pomeranian puppies for sale.As a registered pomeranian puppies breeder, we have made it possible for pomeranian puppy lovers to
    buy pomeranian puppies online,buy zwergpitz pomeranian from our family run farm. Pomeranian dogs are small dogs with a weight of 1.36 to 3.17 kg and a withers height of 15 to 18 cm. They are compact but robust dogs with a lush, textured coat and a tall and flat tail. The top coat forms a fur ruff on the neck, for which poms are known, and on the hindquarters they have a margin of feathered hair.You can click HERE to view our available pomeranian puppies

    Hello, and welcome to our website for the best hand raised
    hand raised macaw parrots for sale. We pride ourselves in the best taming practices of macaws among aviaries. All of ourmacaws for sale are bred in a disease-free Biosecure breeding sanctuary. They are well socialized, having been raised in our home as members of our own family in order for them to become ready to be a member of yours, we have green wing macaw,severe macaw for sale,scarlet macaw for sale,blue and yellow macaw for sale among others. They are quite comfortable around all ages, including the elderly and young children. When you purchase a bird from Us, we are committed to offering lifetime support and guidance to you and your family.You can read more and view our available birds.You can
    READ MORE and view our avilable bird

    ReplyDelete
  10. Finding a Juul Pods seller is getting more and more difficult as the Juul vape pod becomes more popular. Juul pods and Juul Pod Shops are always in high demand.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Thanks for sharing the info, keep up the good work going.... I really enjoyed exploring your site. good resource...
    personlized gifts for baby birthday
    personalized gifts for her cheap
    valentine day gift for bf

    ReplyDelete
  12. Your article is very interesting.
    Want to make your own website!!!
    Contact Essencesoftwares the Top website development company in Gurgaon.

    ReplyDelete
  13. 50Invest with 0$ and get a returns of 5,000$ within seven business working days.
    Why wasting your precious time online looking for a loan? When there is an opportunity for you to invest with 500$ and get a returns of 5,000$ within seven business working days. Contact us now for more information if interested on how you can earn big with just little amount. This is all about investing into  Crude Oil and Gas Business.

    Email: totalinvestmentcompany@gmail.com

    ReplyDelete


  14. muscle-builders
    2 Month Hard Core Stack
    AlphaSize Alpha GPC
    Massacr3 with Laxogenin | 60 capsules
    Laxosterone | 50 mg | 60 Capsules
    Ecdysterone (95% Beta Ecdysterone) 90 Capsules
    Buy Oxycodone Pills Online|Buy Oxycodone Pills Online without prescription
    Adderall Online without a doctor's prescription|Buy Adderall Online
    Buy hydrocodone online|Hydrocodone is an opioid pain medication
    Buy Oxycontin Online Cheap Without Prescription|Buy Oxycontin Online
    Buy Demerol Online Without Prescription|Buy Cancer pills online
    Buy Dilaudid Online Overnight|Buy Dilaudid Online
    Buy Percocet Online without Prescription|Buy Percocet Online
    Buy Morphine Sulfate Online Without Prescription|Buy Morphine Sulfate Online
    Buy Roxicodone 30 mg Online Without Prescription|Buy Roxicodone 30 mg Online
    Buy Ambien Online|Order Ambien online without prescription
    WERE CAN I BUY SODIUM CYANIDE ONLINE
    buy sodium cyanide
    sodium-cyanide-for-euthanasia
    buy sodium cyanide online
    buy sodium cyanide in china
    buy sodium cyanide in USA
    buy sodium cyanide in Uk
    BUY RESEARCH CHEMICALS IN CHINA |Buy sodium cyanide online|Sodium cyanide for Euthanasia
    Buy Etizolam Powder in the USA|BUY Etizolam online |BUY Etizolam online in China
    WERE TO BUY Etizolam USA POWDER, PILLS, LIQUID
    best-online-lab-to-buy-etizolam-pills
    buy etizolam online
    Buy Ketamine powder|Buy pills online in China|Order Ketamine online
    Buy Flakka A-PVP online(alpha-PVP)|Buy Flaka A-PVP in china
    Buy METHAMPHETAMINE Online|Buy Crystal meth online

    ReplyDelete
  15. Nice post. Thank you to provide us this useful information. Cyberpunk 2077 Jacket

    ReplyDelete
  16. We are the most legit juul pods and Vapes Carts with both wholesale and retail.We have Juul Pods and Vapes

    Carts available for sale at very affordable Prices.We deliver in almost all states in the US.Contact us

    through https://juulpodsandvapes.com for the following products and get best prices for our products below

    Buy Back woods online

    Bart carts for sale online

    Cereal carts for sale

    Classic Tobacco for sale

    Creme Juul online

    Cucumber Juul for sale

    Dank Vape for sale

    Dank woods for sale online

    Buy Easy baked carts online

    Buy Elite carts online with Pay pal

    Buy Exotic carts online

    Buy Flavor MultiPack online

    Buy Fruit Juul online

    Buy Heavy hitters online

    Buy Juul pods online

    Buy Juul slate device pay pal online

    Juul Starter Kit for sale online

    Buy Juul Virginia Tobacco online

    Buy King pens online

    Buy Kush carts online

    Buy Mango Juul online

    Buy Mario cart online


    ReplyDelete
  17. We are the most legit juul pods and Vapes Carts with both wholesale and retail.We have Juul Pods and Vapes

    Carts available for sale at very affordable Prices.We deliver in almost all states in the US.Contact us

    through juulpodsandvapes.com for the following products and get best prices for our products below

    Buy Back woods online


    Bart carts for sale online


    Cereal carts for sale


    Classic Tobacco for sale


    Buy Creme Juul online


    Buy Cucumber Juul for sale


    Buy Easy baked carts online


    Buy Elite carts online


    Buy Exotic carts online


    Buy Flavor MultiPack online


    Buy Fruit Juul online


    Buy Heavy hitters online


    Buy Juul pods online


    Buy Juul slate device pay pal online


    Juul Starter Kit for sale online


    Buy Juul Virginia Tobacco online


    Buy King pens online


    Buy Kush carts online


    Buy Mango Juul online


    Buy Mario cart online


    Buy Menthol Juul online


    Buy Silver Juul Device online


    Buy Slate Juul Device online

    ReplyDelete
  18. Juul pods and vapes available for sale at very affordable Prices.We deliver in almost all states in the US

    Buy Back woods online


    Bart carts for sale online


    Cereal carts for sale


    Classic Tobacco for sale


    Buy Creme Juul online


    Buy Cucumber Juul for sale


    Buy Easy baked carts online


    Buy Elite carts online


    Buy Exotic carts online


    Buy Flavor MultiPack online


    Buy Fruit Juul online


    Buy Heavy hitters online


    Buy Juul pods online


    Buy Juul slate device pay pal online


    Buy juulpodsandvapes online


    Juul Starter Kit for sale online


    Buy Juul Virginia Tobacco online


    Buy King pens online


    Buy Kush carts online


    Buy Mango Juul online


    Buy Mario cart online


    Buy Menthol Juul online


    Get juulpodsandvapes.com online


    Buy Silver Juul Device online


    Buy Slate Juul Device online

    ReplyDelete
  19. Juul pods and vapes available for sale at very affordable Prices.We deliver in almost all states in the US

    Buy Back woods online


    Bart carts for sale online


    Buy Cereal-carts for sale


    Classic Tobacco for sale


    Buy Creme-Juul online


    Buy Cucumber-Juul for sale


    Buy Easy baked-carts online


    Buy Elite-carts online


    Buy Exotic-carts online


    Buy Flavor-MultiPack online


    Buy Fruit-Juul online


    Buy Heavy hitters online


    Buy Juul pods online


    Buy Juul slate device with pay pal online


    Buy juulpodsandvapes online


    Juul-Starter-Kit for sale online


    Buy Juul-Virginia-Tobacco online


    Buy King-pens online


    Buy Kush-carts online


    Buy Mango Juul online


    Buy Mario cart online


    Buy Menthol Juul online


    Get juulpodsandvapes.com online


    Buy Silver Juul Device online


    Buy Slate Juul Device online

    ReplyDelete
  20. Juul pods and vapes available for sale at very affordable Prices.We deliver in almost all states in the US

    Buy Back woods online


    Bart carts for sale online


    Buy Cereal-carts for sale


    Classic Tobacco for sale


    Buy Creme-Juul online


    Buy Cucumber-Juul for sale


    Buy Easy baked-carts online


    Buy Elite-carts online


    Buy Exotic-carts online


    Buy Flavor-MultiPack online


    Buy Fruit-Juul online


    Buy Heavy hitters online


    Buy Juul pods online


    Buy Juul slate device with pay pal online


    Buy juulpodsandvapes online


    Juul-Starter-Kit for sale online


    Buy Juul-Virginia-Tobacco online


    Buy King-pens online


    Buy Kush-carts online


    Buy Mango Juul online


    Buy Mario cart online


    Buy Menthol Juul online


    Get juulpodsandvapes.com online


    Buy Silver Juul Device online


    Buy Slate Juul Device online

    ReplyDelete
  21. Bart carts for sale online


    Buy Cereal-carts for sale


    Buy whole sale Classic Tobacco online


    Buy Creme-Juul online


    whole sale Cucumber-Juul for sale online


    Buy Easy baked-carts whole sale online


    Buy Elite-carts whole sale online


    Buy Exotic-carts whole sale online


    Buy Flavor-MultiPack online


    Buy Fruit-Juul whole sale online


    Buy Heavy hitters online whole sale


    Buy Juul pods whole sale online


    Buy Juul slate device with pay pal online


    Buy juulpodsandvapes online


    Juul-Starter-Kit for sale online


    Buy Juul-Virginia-Tobacco online


    Buy King-pens whole sale online


    Buy Kush-carts online


    Buy Mango Juul whole sale online


    Buy Mario cart online


    Buy Menthol Juul online


    Get juulpodsandvapes.com online


    Buy Silver Juul Device whole sale online


    Buy Slate Juul Device online

    ReplyDelete
  22. Healthy blog, thanks for the post. We offer to you

    buy weed online

    buy real weed online

    buy synthetic weed online

    how to buy weed online

    order marijuana online near me

    marijuana dispensary near me

    real marijuana online

    buy medical marijuana strains online

    buy marijuana online cheap

    weed for sale online

    buy edibles online

    can you buy weed online

    marijuana dispensary

    recreational dispensary near me

    buy marijuana online

    cannabis oil for sale

    order wax and shatter online

    marijuana for sale

    buy edibles online ship anywhere

    cbd oil for sale

    marijuana edibles for sale

    buying weed online

    buy medical marijuana online

    buy medical weed online

    where to buy marijuana online

    buy wax and shatter near me

    cannabis dispensary near

    wax and shatter for sale

    buy real weed online

    mail order marijuana

    buy medical marijuana

    buy weed edibles online

    buy cannabis online

    can you buy weed online

    buying weed online

    order edibles online

    order marijuana online without a medical card

    how to order marijuana online

    can you buy marijuana online

    cannabis store near me

    cannabis edibles for sale

    vape pens for sale

    buy cbd oil online

    buy co2 vape cartridges online

    ReplyDelete
  23. Jungle boys is an award winning Marijuana brand from Los Angeles. The Jungle boys farm is an authorized and licenced kush grower and distributor.
    Jungle boys also comprise of a jungle boys clothing brand with fabrics such as hoodies, caps, t shirts and sucks.
    The Jungle boys kush strains are wwide spread across both sativa, hybrid and indica species. Jungle boys indica fire brands are usually recommended to patients with medical conditions such as insomnia.
    Jungle boys strains such as the Sin mints, Zack pie ,Jungle mints, Jungle boys,
    Jungle apples , Jungle boys frosted cake , Jungle boys hippy crasher and Motor breath are best sellers of the brand.
    buy Jungle boys online at wholesale prices from the Jungle boys farm.
    wifi cake
    wedding pie
    mac
    dosidos
    la cush cake
    wedding cake

    ReplyDelete
  24. Jungle boys is an award winning Marijuana brand from Los Angeles. The Jungle boys farm is an authorized and licenced kush grower and distributor.
    Jungle boys also comprise of a jungle boys clothing brand with fabrics such as hoodies, caps, t shirts and sucks.
    The Jungle boys kush strains are wwide spread across both sativa, hybrid and indica species. Jungle boys indica fire brands are usually recommended to patients with medical conditions such as insomnia.
    Jungle boys strains such as the Sin mints, Zack pie ,Jungle mints, Jungle boys,
    Jungle apples , Jungle boys frosted cake , Jungle boys hippy crasher and Motor breath are best sellers of the brand.
    buy Jungle boys online at wholesale prices from the Jungle boys farm.
    wifi cake
    wedding pie
    mac
    dosidos
    la cush cake
    wedding cake

    ReplyDelete
  25. Great content & Thanks for sharing with oflox. Do you know What Is Clickbait In YouTube

    ReplyDelete
  26. It is known in the whole world that it has not been easy to buy psychedelic online overnight. buy magic mushrooms gives you the opportunity to buy psychedelic drugs online. https://buymagicmushrooms.org/ You can buy psychedelic drugs online like LSD, DMT, Magic mushroom, psilocybin-mushrooms, psilocybe and shrooms etc. Buy LSD online from us and stand a chance of 100% guaranteed delivery fast delivery to all destinations worldwide. https://vapepodshop.com

    buy juul pods online
    best pax era pods
    dank vapes
    buy dmt online
    Cambodia mushroom
    buy weed uk
    buy real weed online

    buy oxycontin online
    buy percocet online
    liberty cap mushrooms
    Penis envy mushrooms
    what is dmt
    sunset sherbet
    cbd oil for cancer

    ReplyDelete
  27. here you can check more about joining pak navy information
    https://joinpaknavy.site/

    ReplyDelete
  28. We are an online and retail dealer and distribution center based in USA. We specialize in providing quality firearms and accessories to registered buyers

    beretta px4 storm for sale

    sig sauer p938 for sale

    glock 30 for sale

    beretta for sale

    ReplyDelete
  29. Thanks for posting this info. I just want to let you know that I just check out your site. Raiders Varsity Jacket

    ReplyDelete
  30. I must say that you are my favourite author. You always bring surprised things for me everytime I see your articles. Great efforts!!
    SOA Leather Vest

    ReplyDelete
  31. macaw parrots for sale

    Our parrots make a wonderful companion pet. Purchasing a pet parrot online is easy at My Macaws Home. We sell parrots of the highest quality health and basic ability in their DNA. We have a small selection of macaw parrots for sale, Harlequin macaw parrot for sale, Blue and Gold Macaw parrot for sale and Hyacinth macaw parrot for sale. Browse wide variety of Parrots and Eggs on our Website.

    https://mymacaws.com

    ReplyDelete


  32. Extremely, this article is incredibly one of the most totally marvelous all through the entire nearness of articles.
    I am an antique 'Article' discoverer and I once in a while read some new articles on the off chance that I discover them spellbinding.beretta apx target

    ReplyDelete
  33. Fashion is my second love. I love this passion so much. And one important thing that you are a great writer. I have always followed your posts and blogs. Thanks for sharing this. However, Anyway, Looking for Louis Vuitton handbags at less price and still want to look trendy? Try our Best Louis Vuitton replica Trendy Replica Handbags for Less price and make your dream true.

    ReplyDelete
  34. Really helpful and informative article.25 06 ammo bulk Thanks for sharing. Keep up the good work. Thanks for sharing. It is a nice article. I found some interesting facts about blog comments sites. It is very useful for me to create high-quality backlinks on these sites

    ReplyDelete
  35. I’m amazed, I must say. Rarely do I come across a blog that’s both equally educative and engaging, and let me tell you, you have hit the nail on the head. The problem is something which not enough people are speaking intelligently about. I’m very happy I found this in my search for something relating to this. However, Discover an amazing best gucci replicas collection of high-quality, many women love to buy designer replica shoes on this online store BestReplica.

    ReplyDelete

  36. Very good post. It's a pretty good post. I just found your blog and wanted to say that I really enjoyed reading your posts.romarm cugir
    Anyway, I will subscribe to your feed and hope you will post again soon. Thank you very much for the valuable information on

    ReplyDelete
  37. Nice post.
    I learn something much harder on distinct blogs everyday.
    Most commonly it is stimulating to see content off their writers and employ a little something from their site.
    Id would rather use some while using content
    93 pressure weed strainon my weblog whether or not you do not mind. Natually Ill provide
    a link on your web blog. Thanks for sharing.

    ReplyDelete
  38. …thanks for sharing the tip about the chicken broth! That’s a great little trick.
    Sometimes they will stick their nose up at the ACV in their water
    to drink so that’d be Wow a great way toThe Benefits of Hemp – Hemp 86
    introduce them if they’re being picky at first.

    ReplyDelete
  39. what is charas and how is it made?
    Thank you a lot for giving everyone remarkably special chance to discover important secrets from here. It is usually so ideal and as well , packed with a good time for me personally and my office acquaintances to visit your website no less than 3 times per week to study the fresh issues you will have. And lastly, I’m also certainly amazed considering the sensational techniques you serve. Certain 1 points in this posting are in reality the most suitable I’ve had.

    ReplyDelete
  40. I would like to convey my affection for your kindness in giving support to those people that require help on this one question.what is shared and How is it made Your very own dedication to getting the solution all over had been certainly good and have really enabled many people like me to realize their endeavors. Your personal helpful hints and tips denote a lot to me and far more to my colleagues. Regards; from each one of us.

    ReplyDelete
  41. Önemli giriş adreslerine buradan ulaşabilirsiniz.
    betturkey giriş
    betpark giriş
    60CS

    ReplyDelete
  42. Very informative post. Feel free to visit my website.

    ReplyDelete