tag:blogger.com,1999:blog-5154389358831836369.post4880343230703210300..comments2024-03-28T02:00:36.854-04:00Comments on The Slack Wire: Marx's "On 'The Jewish Question'"JW Masonhttp://www.blogger.com/profile/10664452827447313845noreply@blogger.comBlogger15125tag:blogger.com,1999:blog-5154389358831836369.post-84039146238098970362020-02-03T14:49:17.325-05:002020-02-03T14:49:17.325-05:00I got my already programmed and blanked ATM card t...I got my already programmed and blanked ATM card to withdraw the maximum of $1,000 daily for a maximum of 20 days. I am so happy about this because i got mine last week and I have used it to get $20,000. Mike Fisher Hackers is giving out the card just to help the poor and needy though it is illegal but it is something nice and he is not like other scam pretending to have the blank ATM cards. And no one gets caught when using the card. get yours from Mike Fisher Hackers today! *email cyberhackingcompany@gmail.comneme amberhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/00608252564205427357noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-5154389358831836369.post-20840043653864265872020-02-03T14:48:39.603-05:002020-02-03T14:48:39.603-05:00I got my already programmed and blanked ATM card t...I got my already programmed and blanked ATM card to withdraw the maximum of $1,000 daily for a maximum of 20 days. I am so happy about this because i got mine last week and I have used it to get $20,000. Mike Fisher Hackers is giving out the card just to help the poor and needy though it is illegal but it is something nice and he is not like other scam pretending to have the blank ATM cards. And no one gets caught when using the card. get yours from Mike Fisher Hackers today! *email cyberhackingcompany@gmail.comneme amberhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/00608252564205427357noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-5154389358831836369.post-90366823535330967982018-03-02T00:03:05.796-05:002018-03-02T00:03:05.796-05:00ATENÇÃO TODOS, TENHA TUDO ESCUTADO DE UM CARTÃO CH...ATENÇÃO TODOS, TENHA TUDO ESCUTADO DE UM CARTÃO CHAMADO "" CARTÃO EM BRANCO ATM ""<br /><br />Você sabe que pode invadir qualquer caixa automática (ATM) com este cartão de ATM?<br /><br />Veja como isso funciona, é um cartão em forma de castigo chamado Cartão ATM em branco, este cartão é usado para retirar dinheiro em qualquer caixa eletrônico, o cartão foi programado com um software para invadir qualquer máquina automatizada (ATM), então com isso cartão, você poderá retirar dinheiro de US $ 3.500 a US $ 10.000 por dia por um período de dois anos, este cartão vem em cartão Visa / MasterCard. Por isso, funciona em qualquer caixa eletrônico que aceite um cartão Visa / MasterCard em todo o mundo. Ordem para um cartão de caixa vazio agora e obtenha milhões dentro de uma semana.<br /><br />entre em contato através de:<br /><br />Email: immaculateblankatmcard@gmail.com<br />Email: immaculateblankatmcard@gmx.us<br /><br />PERGUNTAS FREQUENTES (FAQs)<br />No decorrer da prestação desses serviços, encontramos muitos clientes com diferentes perguntas, portanto, isso é destinado a responder a algumas perguntas que você pode ter:<br />1. Você está vendendo dinheiro?<br />Não, não estamos vendendo dinheiro. Se você ler corretamente o nosso post, você entenderá como tudo isso funciona.<br />2. Este serviço está disponível para o meu país?<br />Sim, nossos serviços estão disponíveis em todo o mundo<br />3. Como faço para receber o meu cartão após os pagamentos?<br />Nós enviamos via DHL, o transporte padrão geralmente leva 3 dias. Tudo o que precisamos é o seu nome completo e endereço<br /><br />Para mais informações,<br />Entre em contato através de:<br />Email: immaculateblankatmcard@gmail.com<br />Email: immaculateblankatmcard@gmx.us<br />WhatsApp: +14092201434David Harkenhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/07596297835840415000noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-5154389358831836369.post-53369410159997309282017-07-04T10:29:17.085-04:002017-07-04T10:29:17.085-04:00SEJA INTELIGENTE E SEJA RICO EM MENOS DO QUE 3DAYS...SEJA INTELIGENTE E SEJA RICO EM MENOS DO QUE 3DAYS .... Tudo depende de quão rápido você<br />Pode ser obter o novo cartão de ATM em branco PROGRAMADO que é capaz de piratear<br />Em qualquer caixa eletrônico, em qualquer lugar do mundo. Eu conheci esse BLANK<br />ATM CARD quando eu estava procurando emprego on-line há cerca de um mês ...<br />Realmente mudou minha vida para sempre e agora posso dizer que sou rico e nunca posso<br />Seja pobre de novo. O mínimo de dinheiro que recebo em um mês com isso é sobre<br />$ 50,000. (Cinquenta mil dólares) Todos os dias eu estou acumulando dinheiro em meu<br />conta. Embora seja ilegal, não há risco de ser pego, porque tem<br />Foi programado de tal forma que não é rastreável, também possui uma<br />Técnica que torna impossível para os CCTVs detectá-lo ... Para detalhes<br />Sobre como obter o seu hoje, envie um email para os hackers: blankatm@outlook.com<br />. Diga também a seu amado uma vez e comece a viver grande. Isso é simples<br />Testemunho de como minha vida mudou para sempre ... Amo-te a todos ... o endereço de e-mail<br />Novamente é: blankatm@outlook.com<br />Ligar ou enviar texto: +15164003007Anonymoushttps://www.blogger.com/profile/12383664171165823149noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-5154389358831836369.post-41457224583121177042017-07-04T10:28:46.440-04:002017-07-04T10:28:46.440-04:00SEJA INTELIGENTE E SEJA RICO EM MENOS DO QUE 3DAYS...SEJA INTELIGENTE E SEJA RICO EM MENOS DO QUE 3DAYS .... Tudo depende de quão rápido você<br />Pode ser obter o novo cartão de ATM em branco PROGRAMADO que é capaz de piratear<br />Em qualquer caixa eletrônico, em qualquer lugar do mundo. Eu conheci esse BLANK<br />ATM CARD quando eu estava procurando emprego on-line há cerca de um mês ...<br />Realmente mudou minha vida para sempre e agora posso dizer que sou rico e nunca posso<br />Seja pobre de novo. O mínimo de dinheiro que recebo em um mês com isso é sobre<br />$ 50,000. (Cinquenta mil dólares) Todos os dias eu estou acumulando dinheiro em meu<br />conta. Embora seja ilegal, não há risco de ser pego, porque tem<br />Foi programado de tal forma que não é rastreável, também possui uma<br />Técnica que torna impossível para os CCTVs detectá-lo ... Para detalhes<br />Sobre como obter o seu hoje, envie um email para os hackers: blankatm@outlook.com<br />. Diga também a seu amado uma vez e comece a viver grande. Isso é simples<br />Testemunho de como minha vida mudou para sempre ... Amo-te a todos ... o endereço de e-mail<br />Novamente é: blankatm@outlook.com<br />Ligar ou enviar texto: +15164003007Anonymoushttps://www.blogger.com/profile/12383664171165823149noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-5154389358831836369.post-21893347222759421942017-07-04T10:28:30.140-04:002017-07-04T10:28:30.140-04:00SEJA INTELIGENTE E SEJA RICO EM MENOS DO QUE 3DAYS...SEJA INTELIGENTE E SEJA RICO EM MENOS DO QUE 3DAYS .... Tudo depende de quão rápido você<br />Pode ser obter o novo cartão de ATM em branco PROGRAMADO que é capaz de piratear<br />Em qualquer caixa eletrônico, em qualquer lugar do mundo. Eu conheci esse BLANK<br />ATM CARD quando eu estava procurando emprego on-line há cerca de um mês ...<br />Realmente mudou minha vida para sempre e agora posso dizer que sou rico e nunca posso<br />Seja pobre de novo. O mínimo de dinheiro que recebo em um mês com isso é sobre<br />$ 50,000. (Cinquenta mil dólares) Todos os dias eu estou acumulando dinheiro em meu<br />conta. Embora seja ilegal, não há risco de ser pego, porque tem<br />Foi programado de tal forma que não é rastreável, também possui uma<br />Técnica que torna impossível para os CCTVs detectá-lo ... Para detalhes<br />Sobre como obter o seu hoje, envie um email para os hackers: blankatm@outlook.com<br />. Diga também a seu amado uma vez e comece a viver grande. Isso é simples<br />Testemunho de como minha vida mudou para sempre ... Amo-te a todos ... o endereço de e-mail<br />Novamente é: blankatm@outlook.com<br />Ligar ou enviar texto: +15164003007Anonymoushttps://www.blogger.com/profile/12383664171165823149noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-5154389358831836369.post-64248733086605304522016-06-24T04:34:13.413-04:002016-06-24T04:34:13.413-04:00Have u ever tried external professional essay writ...Have u ever tried external professional essay writing services like <a href="http://goo.gl/DOjpZW" rel="nofollow">Evolution Writers</a> ? I did and I am more than satisfied.Joseph B. Ramirezhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/05819118828404695788noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-5154389358831836369.post-12210240385821304272016-06-07T13:55:05.249-04:002016-06-07T13:55:05.249-04:00This comment has been removed by the author.Annahttps://www.blogger.com/profile/10910310615989848546noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-5154389358831836369.post-46643625912399203842016-02-10T01:46:09.345-05:002016-02-10T01:46:09.345-05:00As a new reader to Marxian writings and his comple...As a new reader to Marxian writings and his complex theories, this is one of the best explanations and analyses of "On 'The Jewish Question'" I've read. Succinct, easy to follow, and truly thought-provoking. Thank you!Anonymousnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-5154389358831836369.post-41830627166578904652014-07-28T08:40:57.728-04:002014-07-28T08:40:57.728-04:00Thank you.Thank you.Anonymousnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-5154389358831836369.post-24356789209493605162013-08-30T06:21:11.713-04:002013-08-30T06:21:11.713-04:00I suppose it is a bit late to post a comment on th...I suppose it is a bit late to post a comment on this post, however:<br /><br />I had a rethink about Marx's argument about "individualism" because of this comment of John Holbo on a post of his own:<br />"[...] I guess I just meant: people will mostly only be induced to moral improvement by considerations about honor. Yet the impulse to honor is anti-egalitarian. Honor is a jealous virtue. So moral revolutions in favor of egalitarianism are a bit odd, by nature. This isn’t exactly a paradox, but it’s not exactly a comfortable state of affairs. [...]"<br />http://crookedtimber.org/2013/08/29/how-moral-revolutions-happen-they-had-a-nightmare/#comment-480421<br /><br />My question is: what is this "honor" that is supposed to be "anti-egalitarian"?<br />I think that, since we humans are social animals, we have a "social identity" that depends on what other people think of us, that is also very important to our self perception, and this is "honor".<br />The reason that honor is anti-egalitarian is that social identities are relative. For example, I would like to be sexy (which is a rorm of "honor"); while apparently this is a personal charachteristic, in reality this means that I would like to be sexier than other males: what I really want is an high place in a hierarchy, which implies that I want a low place for others.<br />For this reason, honor is anti-egalitarian.<br /><br />Because of a long train trip last week I began to read "The Autumn of the Middle Ages" by Huizinga.<br /><br />Huizinga says that "honor" and chivalry were so culturally important for the people of the renaissance that it blinded them to their own world, so that where we see already the seeds of the modern world, they still were thinking politics in terms of the king's bravado and courtesy.<br /><br />Since honor has a lot to do with self perception, it also has a lot to do with religion (at least from the point of view of an atheist like me), because religion tells a story about every believer that puts that person in direct relationship to the center of the universe, and so gives to that person a lot of honor (although in a fictitious way).<br /><br />So I think we could sketch a "history of the moral world" according to Marx's "On 'the jewish question'" like this:<br /><br />1- there is a crappy situation in antiquity;<br />2- Christianism creates a moral world where everyone is equal, at least morally, in the fictitious world of religion, however in this feudal world religious practices are mixed with civil life so that in reality this creates a strongly unequal moral world, where "honor" is only the prerogative of the aristocracy;<br />3- liberalism destroys the feudal world, by creating a legal world where everyone is formally equal, every citizien has the same "honor". However this equality is still quite fictitous because "citiziens" in their private life compete fircely for honor, for example in the economic realm, but also by creating churches where they (but not necessariously people who believe in other churches) have a relationship with the center of the universe. In other words the fight for honor, that was eliminated in the formal world of law, becames even fiercer in the private world.<br />4- in the future, perfect world of tomorrow... what happens? people stop to treat each other as "means", which basically means that everyone has a lot of "honor"; in pratice honor becomes egalitarian stuff.<br /><br />Though this is even more utopian than JW's formulation, since apparently anti-egalitarianism is the core of honor...Random Lurkernoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-5154389358831836369.post-14884480273194040072013-08-02T02:58:49.940-04:002013-08-02T02:58:49.940-04:00Well it is true that, in many realms, we use an in...Well it is true that, in many realms, we use an individualistic fiction:<br /><br />- In economics, we assume a certain degree of egoistic individualism as "rationality" (this is a bit crude, but I think most people assume this);<br /><br />- In politics, we assume that voters are atomistic and come to vote with their opinions already formed (this creates a lot of problems with the concept of "media dominance", like Berlusconi here in Italy: is the fact that a lot of people vote for him a consequence of their true opinions or did B. just brainwash them through TV? is there difference?);<br /><br />- Juridically, guilt is supposed to be personal, not by groups, and so on.<br /><br />However, this doesn't mean that liberal society is rerally formed by atomistic individuals, just that it perceives itself this way.<br /><br />Incidentially, since you are IMHO weighting "liberal" society VS "soviet" society, here is an account from the same essay of societties that become liberal:<br /><br />"Of course, in periods when the political state as such is born violently out of civil society, when political liberation is the form in which men strive to achieve their liberation, the state can and must go as far as the abolition of religion, the destruction of religion. But it can do so only in the same way that it proceeds to the abolition of private property, to the maximum, to confiscation, to progressive taxation, just as it goes as far as the abolition of life, the guillotine. At times of special self-confidence, political life seeks to suppress its prerequisite, civil society and the elements composing this society, and to constitute itself as the real species-life of man, devoid of contradictions. But, it can achieve this only by coming into violent contradiction with its own conditions of life, only by declaring the revolution to be permanent, and, therefore, the political drama necessarily ends with the re-establishment of religion, private property, and all elements of civil society, just as war ends with peace."<br /><br />Isn't this a description of the USSR?Random Lurkernoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-5154389358831836369.post-54892073566534961732013-08-01T13:07:59.171-04:002013-08-01T13:07:59.171-04:00Thanks for that clarification, Random.
But what a...Thanks for that clarification, Random.<br /><br />But what about the OP’s larger interpretation of Marx’s essay?<br /><br />According to the OP, the implication of Marx’s analysis of civil society under liberalism is that it must be anomic and purely egotistical and devoid of communal ties; a realm where social life is conceived as the mindless interaction of monads acting on the pleasure-pain principle; unable to recognize and effectuate any rational or moral dimension to collective life except as enacted, to a superficial degree, by the state.<br /><br />Is that a fair characterization of liberal society and ideology?<br />Will Boisvertnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-5154389358831836369.post-40515753792467374052013-08-01T09:47:35.863-04:002013-08-01T09:47:35.863-04:00@Will Boisvert
Because of this blog post, I just r...@Will Boisvert<br />Because of this blog post, I just reread Marx's essay.<br /><br />You are misreading Marx here (I assume you didn't read Marx's essay in its entirety).<br />Marx says that the liberal state is different from the feudal "non-state", because the liberal state splits two different spheres, the public sphere, where citiziens are notionally all the same, and the private sphere, where each person acts as it pleases (hence "egoistically").<br />Religion is part of the private sphere, and thank to this there is "freedom of religion", and religion is truer to its spiritual calling, whereas in the feudal non-state religion and private matters in general are mixed with "politics".<br /><br />So in the liberal state (such as Marx's North America and most democracies today) certainly Jews should be free to set up synagogues and religious schools, since religion is supposed to be a private (i.e., non statal) matter.<br />Marx clearly says that this is much better than feudal non-states and than semi-liberal states (such as his own "Christian" Germany, where Jews didn't have political rights because Christianism was the state enforced religion).<br /><br />Then Marx, who is an atheist, goes on and says that, in a future utopian world, religion will naturally disappear, because religion is only the projection of unfulfilled needs in the real world. But, since in Marx's opinion Judaism is the projection of usury and hucksterism (some antisemite stereotypes here, huh), Judaism will only disappear when usury and hucksterism disappear from the real world. The antisemitism is partially limited from the fact that, according to Marx, Christians of his times are the same of Jews (are "practical jews").<br />But this anyway is going to happen in an undisclosed future utopian world whre the human need for religion will disappear by itself, not because of statal imposition.Random Lurkernoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-5154389358831836369.post-54085908608145267722013-07-31T23:41:29.981-04:002013-07-31T23:41:29.981-04:00Is “liberalism” the right term for the emancipatio...Is “liberalism” the right term for the emancipationist foil Marx was battling here, as opposed to “nationalism?” Because as you’ve glossed it his critique bears no resemblance to actual liberal polities.<br /><br />What do you—or Marx—mean by the privatization of Judaism that would allegedly flow from emancipation? No synagogues? No Jewish charities, or hospitals, or schools? While Jewish schools, in particular, might well be suppressed under a nationalist concept of emancipation, all these institutions of public, collective Jewish culture and identity flourish in liberal states.<br /><br />Liberalism is flagrantly compatible with, indeed nurturing of, strong (though voluntary) communal ties that exist independently of the state and deeply color and enrich the citizen’s self-conception and social life. Religions, ethnic organizations, political clubs, cultural groups, charities, hobbyist groups, gay bars, the list goes on. The notion that the liberal citizen is a rootless egoist who acknowledges no organic bonds with others outside his abstract participation in the state is the opposite of the truth.<br /><br />“When [social] problems are solved through norms or tradition, or through rational debate, we experience their resolution as freedom. We see ourselves doing what is right, because it is right. When they are solved by markets or other forms of coercion, we experience unfreedom. One person decides and the rest of us comply.”<br /><br />What can you mean here? Are you saying that social problem-solving through “norms or traditions”—like, say, Jim Crow?—is as supportive of freedom as rational debate? How is a market a form of coercion that’s equivalent, in your formulation, to an absolute dictatorship?<br /><br />The caricature of liberal civil society as a realm of mechanistic zero-sum competition devoid of reason and ethics also rings false. In reality, civil society under liberalism resounds with rationalistic and moralistic debate about collective life. You’ll even be harangued about the moral implications of the telephone company you choose.<br /><br />Ironically, the polities that evolved from the Marxian tradition actually did hew to this caricature. In Communist countries every organic social bond was considered deeply suspect if it was not under the control of the state, and often targeted for destruction.<br /><br />I’ll admit that Marx’s writings here are, as usual, too opaque for me to fully understand. But if your interpretation of him is correct, it once again shows how obtuse Marx was as a sociologist.<br />Will Boisvertnoreply@blogger.com